top | item 37495850

(no title)

mariusmg | 2 years ago

> with a fairly steep learning curve and a ton of "tribal knowledge"

Yes, people preffer to debug their own code rather than spend shitload of time to understand Wix/MSI.

Microsoft deciding early on to not produce low cost tools for Windows Installer also didn't helped with the adoption.

discuss

delfinom|2 years ago

The joke is, Microsoft devs even now use NSIS for things like VSCode rather than deal with MSIs lol

But there is the modern implementation of AppX Bundles which was later extended to create MSIX which allows app distribution without the windows store. There are still drawbacks to using MSIX usually because you want to touch Windows in ways you can't inside the sandbox.

WorldMaker|2 years ago

To my understanding, MSIX today supports the full MSI catalog and will do entirely unsandboxed (unattended [0]) installs if you want it to. But you need to understand all the same complexity of MSI to build installers in it. The biggest remaining difference MSIX and MSI is an MSI is a strange nesting doll of ancient binary database formats that is tough to build (which is why WiX exists and is part of why WiX is so complex) whereas MSIX is "just" an ordinary ZIP bundle of your files plus XML manifests. With the final punchline being that those XML manifests have yet another dialect from WiX's ancient MSI-database-influenced XML and of course it also isn't as simple as deleting the WiX compiler and just zipping a WiX project.

In my experience, you can pretty easily write the nice sandboxed MSIX manifests by hand, it's not too bad, but general MSIX doing weird MSI things you still want better more expensive tools to build them (and of course Microsoft themselves still don't exactly provide that and will point you to plenty of expensive third party installer studios for options, many of which are the exact same ones people have been overpaying for decades).

[0] The one complaint I'm aware of is that you can't do custom installer UI and "attended" installs with user choices. There's one MSIX UI and it is barebones but acceptable. That's all you get.