top | item 37594826

(no title)

ryanpandya | 2 years ago

I thought we're pretty clear that it's thanks to absolutely colossal mass, which... Can't really happen on earth since it requires the mass of a huge number of earths.

discuss

order

wheelerof4te|2 years ago

Then we need to find another way to generate fusion power, or admit that it's impossible to do on this planet.

Throwing lumps of cash at fusion power venture capital feels almost like a money-laundering fraud.

ben_w|2 years ago

> Then we need to find another way to generate fusion power, or admit that it's impossible to do on this planet.

Yes. Here are the currently known alternatives off the top of my head:

* Fusion bomb

* Inertial electrostatic confinement (14 year olds have done this for highschool science fair projects)

* Virtual cathodes (Polywell, technically also an IEC variant)

* Magnetic confinement (Tokamaks: the big expensive doughnuts)

* Field-reversed configuration (technically also magnetic, but these are magnetic "smoke rings", Helion Energy does this)

* Z-pinch (again magnetic, but different)

* Laser confinement (NIF)

* Muon-catalyzed fusion (no chance of this becoming mainstream unless we can convince muons to stop decaying)

IIRC all of these have demonstrated that it's physically possible; some even show promise.

(I've been wanting to write a plasma physics simulation to see if I can improve on the Fusor design since I was at university; now chatGPT writes acceptable code, I keep asking myself why I've not yet made this happen…)

varjag|2 years ago

The whole fusion energy effort since 1950s is about finding another way.

Maken|2 years ago

At least it's not crypto and it's not actively hurting anyone.