[kaylynb]

Linux is about as consistent as Windows these days. /etc isn’t really a “dumping ground” for everything and is quite static now. Just diffed a snapshot of /etc on my workstation from a month ago and there aren’t really any changes I didn’t put there myself. It’s reasonable to make /etc immutable on a lot of systems; something impossible with the registry.

Home is a bit more chaotic but most applications follow the XDG specs. Mostly. Less so with cache and state files (vscode, for example, dumps tons of cache/state files in .config instead of .cache and .local/state). And weird things like Flatpak shoving everything in .var.

I’d say things generally behave about as well as windows apps which often treat documents as a dumping ground for all kinds of files. I always have to go to pcgamingwiki to find game data locations without having to check half a dozen places.

For administration I really like the /usr and /etc divide. Vendor files go on /usr, and overrides for the running system in /etc. It’s useful to be able to peek in /usr to see defaults.You don’t really get that ability with the registry. With some more modern setups /etc is bootstrapped from /usr (for example, with systemd-tmpfiles) and you can “factory reset” a system by clearing out /etc (with some asterisks around restoring state for a few of the legacy state files still kept in /etc if the system is has manually created users/groups).