top | item 37982963

(no title)

f233f2 | 2 years ago

If we are to tax people because they benefit from public services, then poor people should be taxed more than rich people since they benefit from those services more.

discuss

order

badcppdev|2 years ago

No rich people benefit more. They rely on the rule of law in a nation state to protect their assets and provide a supply of goods and services. And they don't pay much for it (in percentage terms definitely).

f233f2|2 years ago

Poor people cause much, much, much more work to law enforcement and the judicial system than rich people.

michpoch|2 years ago

> They rely on the rule of law in a nation state to protect their assets and provide a supply of goods and services. Which as a result let their companies prosper and that benefits the employees.

> And they don't pay much for it Not true

> (in percentage terms definitely). Why would it matter?

altacc|2 years ago

No, governments are not piggy banks, you don't get out what you put in. People pay taxes for the general betterment of the country and everyone benefits from a stable country with a healthy population, which are things you can't really place a monetary value on.

kleene_op|2 years ago

Rich people benefit from all the poor people benefiting from public services. No Uber drivers without public roads.

f233f2|2 years ago

Uber drivers are poor people.