top | item 38423357

(no title)

sander1095 | 2 years ago

Windows has had `winget` as a central package manager for a while now. It works great!

discuss

order

iscream26|2 years ago

I wouldn't be that enthusiastic about it. Best I can say is that it is not terrible. In simplified terms, all it does is download exe files from URL addresses that it gets from yaml metadata files, and then silently executes them; which in turn means that it leaves all of the installer's checkboxes unmodified, cluttering your desktop with icons in the process. On top of that, Windows Terminal has been failing to update on my machine as of late. I don't think this should be the standard for a first-party package manager, but I'd say it's par for the course for Microsoft.

It's also worth noting that all of Winget's code was initially taken from AppGet, without much recognition.[1] Apparently Microsoft cared just enough about that detail to mention the project they forked in passing, as part of a list of third-party package manager projects for Windows.[2] This is why, IMO, you should always first consider a copyleft license for an open source project.

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/28/21272964/microsoft-winget...

[2] https://devblogs.microsoft.com/commandline/windows-package-m...

EDIT: fixed vertical spacing.

ndsipa_pomu|2 years ago

Thanks - this is the first that I'm hearing about it, though I don't use Windows that often.

Do many third parties use it?