top | item 38559232

(no title)

randomizedalgs | 2 years ago

As a super minor grammar point for the author, "ubiquitous" is a rare example of a word that starts with a vowel but should be proceeded by "a" instead of "an".

discuss

order

jjtheblunt|2 years ago

I think that's got to be a great test for foreign spies!

"ubiquitous" starts with the sound of "you-biquitous" and so the suffix -n is a duplicated non-vowel. ("y" is probably a vocalic glide, but still not in {a,e,i,o,u}.)

I bet the real rule is some reality about feasibility of pronunciation, even though native english speakers see the rules explained in terms of spellings.

JoshTriplett|2 years ago

> I bet the real rule is some reality about feasibility of pronunciation, even though native english speakers see the rules explained in terms of spellings.

The rule as often given in English classes is to use "an" if a word starts with a "vowel sound", rather than starting with a vowel. So, it's "an herb" (since the 'h' is silent in (American) English), but "a ubiquitous".

Relatedly, you can infer whether someone likely pronounces "URL" by spelling it out (like "you are ell") or as a word (like "earl") based on whether they write "a URL" or "an URL".

loxias|2 years ago

> I bet the real rule is some reality about feasibility of pronunciation

YUP! Sorry I don't have a good citation handy, but lots of English grammar happens as a result of misaligned word boundaries. "napron" (from the French naperon) became "an apron". Orange (from the Arabic naranj)... "an ewt" became "a newt". etc.

taneq|2 years ago

It's regional depending on silent or transmuted consonants in the local vernacular. An 'ospital, an 'orse, a nuncle, it's a yewbiquitous phenomenon.

tomrod|2 years ago

Oy, keep yer spillage off my napron!

ithkuil|2 years ago

A union

A urinal

...