top | item 38580852

(no title)

photonerd | 2 years ago

Doesn’t need to have a transaction to be stealing. You just need to take (or appropriate) something that you’re not allowed to.

discuss

order

123pie123|2 years ago

this has been said many many times - nothing is taken

people are copying

and what do you mean by "you're not allowed to"

shinycode|2 years ago

There is thousands of hours of paid work to produce any kind of software or game. It doesn’t matter if the end result is burned into a physical disk or not. What’s of value here is not the 1 cent piece of plastic but the content.

When you copy content that has a cost, if the company is not offering it to you, what do you call your action ?

I mean, really, you spent 5 years working on a game with no salary. Then a day before launch day someone just makes a copy of it and distributed it « for free » in the internet. How are you going to make a salary out of it ?

photonerd|2 years ago

Taking just means, broadly, “to gain or acquire”. Repetition of an incorrect point doesn’t make it any more valid I’m afraid.

Copying is often called taking a copy. Even basic usage of the term copying invalidates your point!

As for “not allowed” that will vary by contract/law/agreement/license/etc

This distinction is why it’s usually not downloaders that are punished, rather uploaders: they’re the ones that broke an agreement.