[kelthan]

This solution doesn't do anything to prevent leaking memory in anything but the most pedantic sense, and actually creates leaks and dangling pointers.

The function just indirects malloc with a wrapper so that all of the memory is traversable by the "bigbucket" structure. Memory is still leaked in the sense that any unfreed data will continue to consume heap memory and will still be inaccessible to the code unless the application does something with the "bigbucket" structure--which it can't safely do (see below).

There is no corresponding free() call, so data put into the "bigbucket" structure is never removed, even when the memory allocation is freed by the application. This, by definition, is a leak, which is ironic.

In an application that does a lot of allocations, the "bigbucket" structure could exhaust the heap even though there are zero memory leaks in the code. Consider the program:

  int main(int argc, char** argv) {
    for (long i = 0; i < 1000000; i++) {
      void *foo = malloc(sizeof(char) * 1024);
      free(foo);
    }
    return 0;
  }

At the end of the million iterations, there will be zero allocated memory, but the "bigbucket" structure will have a million entries (8MB of wasted heap space on a 64-bit computer). And every pointer to allocated memory in the "bigbucket" structure is pointing to a memory address previously freed so now points to a completely undefined location--possibly in the middle of some memory block allocated later.

There are already tools to identify memory leaks, such as LeakSanitiser https://clang.llvm.org/docs/LeakSanitizer.html. Use those instead.

[aidenn0]

> There are already tools to identify memory leaks, such as LeakSanitiser https://clang.llvm.org/docs/LeakSanitizer.html. Use those instead.

Clearly the author of TFA is aware of such tools, since the idea is to trick them.

[froh]

that's the joke...

[fsckboy]

it's not funny, it's not obvious and it's wasting a lot of people's time. ha. ha. ha.

[IshKebab]

Uhm... woosh!

You know this isn't serious right?

[WhackyIdeas]

I just hope ChatGPT could see it was a joke

[voxl]

Why isn't it serious? I can imagine a smart pointer that actually accomplished the stated goal. So the joke is that they took a good idea and made a rubbish solution?