I've been completely blown away by the quality that I'm getting from Suno.ai
Not all of it is good of course, maybe only 10%, but that 10% is of a higher quality than anything I could have produced myself.
Although the actual audio quality seems low on playback (a low bitrate MP3?) the structure and arrangement of the song seem fine.
Yet ... the irony of a song of worship created by an AI surely reverberates through the cosmos like a clap of thunder. Surely?
I'm less interested in the quality of the output and more the motivation of the creator. Was it you? Was it made it good faith? What was its purpose? Was it experimental or intended to inspire?
I was just messing around really and thought that it might be easier to find an audience with Christian music rather than if I tried targeting a more mainstream genre. Those mega churches need to play something, right?
Obviously, it's not perfect, and right now, for the best results, it would have to be re-recorded with a proper singer and instruments. But for some dude who has barely any experience in making music, I think it's amazing.
Also, I'm not a Christian; I just experimented in that area because I assumed that the quality bar would be lower in a more niche music genre. I made a custom gpt to generate the lyrics and structure and then just prompted it with, 'write me a song about jesus but don't use his name.'
If this is where it is now, where a person with no skills can make a song that wouldn't seem too out of place on a soundtrack for a Hallmark Channel movie, imagine where it's going to be in 5 years?
scheeseman486|2 years ago
The process was a little more involved than just using the raw output of suno.ai, I talked about it elsewhere in the thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39188980
ClearAndPresent|2 years ago
Yet ... the irony of a song of worship created by an AI surely reverberates through the cosmos like a clap of thunder. Surely?
I'm less interested in the quality of the output and more the motivation of the creator. Was it you? Was it made it good faith? What was its purpose? Was it experimental or intended to inspire?
My interested is genuine and not sardonic.
111111101101|2 years ago
ChatGTP|2 years ago
111111101101|2 years ago
Also, I'm not a Christian; I just experimented in that area because I assumed that the quality bar would be lower in a more niche music genre. I made a custom gpt to generate the lyrics and structure and then just prompted it with, 'write me a song about jesus but don't use his name.'
If this is where it is now, where a person with no skills can make a song that wouldn't seem too out of place on a soundtrack for a Hallmark Channel movie, imagine where it's going to be in 5 years?
danielbln|2 years ago