I've always found this reasoning insane. People are in a position where they want, or feel it's the only option, to kill themselves. And someone suggests the problem is access to the ability to do so, rather than what lead them to feel that way?
Guns, drugs, knifes, rope, exhaust, whatever. These always become the focus when a kid kills themselves. How about the circumstances that led to it? Suicide is still a problem is low gun ownership countries.
It is certainly part of the problem, but it's not the root cause.
Yes. Access to and knowledge of firearms dramatically increases the lethality of suicide attempts.
But in this case, the kid was scammed for nudes and then blackmailed with them. Without easy access to guns, he could have survived the suicide attempt, but there's no guarantee.
The root cause has more to do with childhood, internet access, and maybe even parent-child relationships.
To add to the sibling comments, Japan has very restrictive gun laws [1], but a suicide rate (12.2) similar to the US (14.5) [2]. Let me add that I find the instinct to restrict personal freedom as the very first measure very disturbing. As if the loss of freedom is not a harm in itself. More pragmatically, how many people will admit to being suicidal, if the immediate consequence is being locked in a padded room without so much as a shoelace?
To this American's eyes, not mentioning that at all is a glaring omission. I recognize they might not want to in the story of the representative's son (as it might come across as blaming the parents in a recent tragedy) but even though it's for sure relevant in the aggregate.
This is a yes-and situation (that is, the issues are orthogonal). There are several similar stories where firearms access is not a factor (Amanda Todd is one of the most well-known, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Amanda_Todd). Various social media networks are implicated as factors.
xboxnolifes|2 years ago
Guns, drugs, knifes, rope, exhaust, whatever. These always become the focus when a kid kills themselves. How about the circumstances that led to it? Suicide is still a problem is low gun ownership countries.
theGnuMe|2 years ago
So yes access to guns is a problem.
https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/magazine/magazine_article/guns-...
dudul|2 years ago
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Amanda_Todd
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Tyler_Clementi
Teenagers don't need a gun to kill themselves. This is not the issue at hands here.
curtis3389|2 years ago
Yes. Access to and knowledge of firearms dramatically increases the lethality of suicide attempts.
But in this case, the kid was scammed for nudes and then blackmailed with them. Without easy access to guns, he could have survived the suicide attempt, but there's no guarantee.
The root cause has more to do with childhood, internet access, and maybe even parent-child relationships.
jevoten|2 years ago
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overview_of_gun_laws_by_nation...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_r...
tmdyn|2 years ago
xboxnolifes|2 years ago
telotortium|2 years ago
halostatue|2 years ago