top | item 39244524

(no title)

lemmox | 2 years ago

Yes, I recall this as well. It didn't pass the smell test to me - probably wineries making up a reason to justify switching to screw caps.

discuss

order

eikenberry|2 years ago

Especially funny given that screw caps are inherently superior in every way except for hipster signalling.

genocidicbunny|2 years ago

Well, not superior in every way.

If you don't drink a lot of wine in one sitting and have bottles that have been opened, corks seem to average out to being better for re-sealing the bottle -- specifically if you're placing them horizontally, like in a wine cooler. I've found screw caps frequently tend to leak, even over a single evening. Even with the hole from the corkscrew, the cork tends to reseal better from my experience.

With that said, I am talking about actual cork and not the plastic versions; Those will seep just as bad as screw caps.

pyrale|2 years ago

...And for plastic caps ending up in the sea for a few centuries.

wolverine876|2 years ago

> hipster

Vinophiles are now considered 'hipsters'? Is there any less hipster crowd than uber-wealthy wine collectors, a hobby dating back generations, if not centuries?

loeg|2 years ago

Screw caps are superior anyway. A better seal, easier to open, easier to reseal. It's good to see some reasonably good wines adopting screw tops in spite of tradition/inertia.

yeeeloit|2 years ago

They are not superior. Convenient in certain circumstances, perhaps.

For example if one cannot be bothered to use, or does not have a corkscrew handy, a screw cap might be preferred for some.

I know it is difficult for most Modern Americans to use a corkscrew. Even more difficult is being able to appreciate the complexities and effort that goes into making good, traditional wine. Best to do away with tradition for the sake of convenience.