top | item 39337310

(no title)

corethree | 2 years ago

Is there a way to model this theoretically? Or is it always trial and error?

I mean I realize you have to test the thing for "bugs" just wondering if a theory to perfectly model it is even possible.

discuss

order

dutchkiwifruit|2 years ago

Some things certainly can be modelled, but for others it is easier to simply try. For example, will applying a positive current to the motor make it spin in the clockwise or counterclockwise direction? It really depends on the behaviour and configuration of the motor controller, and in this case it was easier for me to just try.

The trick is to do these tests at a sufficiently low level, because that’s usually where these issues are, in my experience.

dgoldstein0|2 years ago

I think it's possible. But you'd have to be really careful with your equations, then have to be really careful to know which direction is positive in each signal and make sure to make the wiring and/or math match that. I can see why some trial and error would be easier than completely rechecking things when they don't work.

corethree|2 years ago

Does anyone know what I have to learn to "know" about this theory? Is it control theory and classical mechanics?

lupire|2 years ago

Of course. The OP was modeling it theoretically, but making mistakes.