Nobody remotely versed in this stuff would expect SMS to be end-to-end encrypted, though to be honest the more notable fact to me here is that Apple can read any plaintext in your backups. iMessage is an over the top messaging service more akin to WhatsApp or Signal than it is to SMS, so that is a more relevant comparison. I don't know if any of the clients store plaintext messages that would be backed up to Apple in a similar manner or not, but I'd hope at least the more security focused ones do not.Apple makes privacy claims about iMessage including 'Apple can’t decrypt the data.', which is notably false in this (common) scenario, and requires a large asterisk on those claims, IMO bordering on making them unethical, period.
No comments yet.