The images are generated, but the training set may be argued or not that they had some rights attached, even it they were the ones that the social network where they were posted and scrapped from had.
There are is money to be made in a way or another, same with music, wouldn’t be surprised if this kind of projects get hit directly or indirectly because of this.
Yeah it's going to be a lightning rod for copyright trolls if it gets popular. Ultimately that's a good thing. There's precedents that need to be worked out, and if they go the wrong way, consequences that will need to be lived with that hopefully restore common sense. It's not that different from the Napster days other than an infinitely weaker case for the copyright trolls.
I'm working on a golf startup atm, so this is relevant.
These are certainly generated, as virtually every golf club has an insane and unworkable head, just like Midjourney. AI doesn't seem to focus on that level of detail. Take this one for example which would launch the ball somewhere into the sun: https://stockcake.com/i/golf-swing-action_656275_515716
Others look something like a soup plate attached to a stick, and it is common to see right handed players using left handed clubs.
I wonder if these images might still get you in trouble if they show copyrighted work like the Eiffeltower at night, the opera house in Sydney or Atomium in Brussels
machine generated works cannot be copyrighted, but its a legal gray area as to whether creating the images violates copyright (in my opinion it is not fair use, as it displaces the market value of the work it is a derivative of)
Must add that even if this is is not 100% quality, it is a HUUUGE threat to paid stock photos... I mean for 0 dollars why wouldn't you lower your bar little bit... or with some photos you get much better results with ai.
I'll bet Adobe or similiar will buy this 0,5 mil and just delete
"The fingers are curled into the well-known peace sign, symbolizing tranquility, harmony, and non-violence. The neatly trimmed nails and smooth skin suggest a sense of care and refinement, while the gesture itself—a silent but powerful expression of hope and solidarity—resonates universally across cultures and languages."
gmuslera|1 year ago
There are is money to be made in a way or another, same with music, wouldn’t be surprised if this kind of projects get hit directly or indirectly because of this.
andy99|1 year ago
beachy|1 year ago
These are certainly generated, as virtually every golf club has an insane and unworkable head, just like Midjourney. AI doesn't seem to focus on that level of detail. Take this one for example which would launch the ball somewhere into the sun: https://stockcake.com/i/golf-swing-action_656275_515716
Others look something like a soup plate attached to a stick, and it is common to see right handed players using left handed clubs.
tveita|1 year ago
Let's see how it does with Native American
https://stockcake.com/i/historical-handshake-moment_626739_3...
https://stockcake.com/i/historical-handshake-moment_626741_3...
These could cause some upset... If you have to do this maybe at least avoid publishing anything tagged "History"?
https://stockcake.com/i/reindeer-caravan-march_309941_464989
Northern natives all have horns, right?
jazzyjackson|1 year ago
jsheard|1 year ago
https://stockcake.com/i/golfers-perfect-swing_656278_515716
They have some very specific niches covered though, such as "soldier petting a dog with both right hands"
https://stockcake.com/i/soldier-embracing-dog_655559_294061
And "cat space adventure, wait, oh god we accidentally overfitted the model on dogecoin memes"
https://stockcake.com/i/cosmic-cat-adventure_353671_432927
mcamac|1 year ago
naiv|1 year ago
UberFly|1 year ago
traverseda|1 year ago
https://stockcake.com/i/wine-celebration-setup_855871_108599...
anonymous344|1 year ago
but where are the images from ? scraped or self generated? how can i make sure that they are not copyrighted?
jazzyjackson|1 year ago
binarymax|1 year ago
abound|1 year ago
Depending on the licenses of the content it was trained on, this could be an elaborate way of "laundering" commercial stock photos and other content.
Of course, the legality of such things is being very actively litigated, will be interesting to see where it lands.
anonymous344|1 year ago
I'll bet Adobe or similiar will buy this 0,5 mil and just delete
zingelshuher|1 year ago
May be that was the business plan, or 'plan B'
sebastiennight|1 year ago
dulvui|1 year ago
spacechild1|1 year ago
https://stockcake.com/i/peace-sign-gesture_399087_107292
https://stockcake.com/i/signaling-peace-sign_446139_596168
https://stockcake.com/i/peaceful-demonstration-outdoors_7056...
"The fingers are curled into the well-known peace sign, symbolizing tranquility, harmony, and non-violence. The neatly trimmed nails and smooth skin suggest a sense of care and refinement, while the gesture itself—a silent but powerful expression of hope and solidarity—resonates universally across cultures and languages."
Well, almost...
brokenmachine|1 year ago
dvh|1 year ago