[Twinklebear]

Author of the WebGL volume rendering tutorial [0] you mentioned in the readme here, great work!

Working in WebGL/JS is nice since you can deploy it everywhere, but it can be really hard for graphics programming as you've found because there are very few tools for doing real GPU/graphics debugging for WebGL. The only one I know of is [1], and I've had limited success with it.

WebGPU is a great next step, it provides a modern GPU API (so if you want to learn Metal, DX12, Vulkan, they're more familiar), and modern GPU functionality like storage buffers and compute shaders, not to mention lower overhead and better performance. The WebGPU inspector [2] also looks to provide a GPU profiler/debugger for web that aims to be on par with native options. I just tried it out on a small project I have and it looks really useful. Another benefit of WebGPU is that it maps more clearly to Metal/DX12/Vulkan, so you can use native tools to profile it through Chrome [3].

I think it would be worth learning C++ and a native graphics API, you'll get access to the much more powerful graphics debugging & profiling features provided by native tools (PIX, RenderDoc, Nvidia Nsight, Xcode, etc.) and functionality beyond what even WebGPU exposes.

Personally, I have come "full circle": I started with C++ and OpenGL, then DX12/Vulkan/Metal, then started doing more WebGL/WebGPU and JS/TS to "run everywhere", and now I'm back writing C++ but using WebGL/WebGPU and compiling to WebAssembly to still run everywhere (and native for tools).

With WebGPU, you could program in C++ (or Rust) and compile to both native (for access to debuggers and tools), and Wasm (for wide deployment on the web). This is one of the aspects of WebGPU that is most exciting to me. There's a great tutorial on developing WebGPU w/ C++ [4], and a one on using it from JS/TS [5].

[0] https://www.willusher.io/webgl/2019/01/13/volume-rendering-w...

[1] https://spector.babylonjs.com/

[2] https://github.com/brendan-duncan/webgpu_inspector

[3] https://toji.dev/webgpu-profiling/pix

[4] https://eliemichel.github.io/LearnWebGPU/

[5] https://webgpufundamentals.org/

[SuboptimalEng]

Wow! First of all, thank you for your amazing blog posts and tutorials! I wouldn't have been able to make it this far without them. Seriously, I was stuck for so long until a random Google search linked me to that WebGL ray-casting article you wrote. (I'd pin your comment if I could.)

The funny thing is that I was getting more confident about using JS + WebGL/WebGPU ecosystem for graphics programming after having read your posts. Very interesting to hear that you've come full circle back to Cpp + WebGL/WebGPU + WebAssembly. I'll look more closely to assess options as I head down this journey. Thank you for your tips and advice!

Edit: Perhaps you'd find my "What is WebGPU" video on YouTube interesting. I'd love to get it fact-checked by someone who's been doing WebGl/WebGPU way longer than most people! I only got into this field ~2 years ago.

[Twinklebear]

Sure I'd be happy to check it out, my email's in my profile (or Github/website).

There are some tradeoffs w/ WebAssembly as well (not sharing the same memory as JS/TS is the biggest one) and debugging can be a bit tough as well though now there's a good VSCode plugin for it [0]. Another part of the reason I also moved back to C++ -> Wasm was for the performance improvement from Wasm vs. JS/TS, but the cross compilation to native/web was the main motivator.

[0] https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=ms-vscod...