WingNews logo WingNews
top | item 40373897

(no title)

daniel_grady | 1 year ago

I made a serious effort to integrate Muse into my work starting around late 2021 or early 2022, and in fact bought an iPad Mini and Apple Pencil specifically to use Muse. The work that comes out of Ink & Switch is always interesting, and I was excited to try some of it out in the real world. Over a year or so, I used it to read and review PDFs (mostly journal articles for work), wrote and presented a lunch-and-learn from Muse, dropped PNG plots from Jupyter for scribbling or easy comparison; I even got one of my colleagues interested enough to use the collaboration features semi-regularly.

It hasn’t stuck though, and I’ve stopped using it; subscription will lapse later this year. I’m sad; like others here I really wanted to like this and for it to make sense to keep using.

I don’t a have clear set of reasons for why it didn’t stick. Just thinking out loud. Partially, I was fighting against my organization — my immediate team is science / Apple / Python, but the larger company is Teams / Windows / PowerPoint, and that’s always friction. Partially, it was a workflow thing — most often I wanted to review PDFs, which live in Zotero, and then it’s like, did I copy that one over yet? Where are my notes about that one? Muse’s PDF excerpting feature is really wonderful; the lack of being able to zoom a PDF, or support for table of contents, was a bummer. Large PDFs like textbooks could be problematic. Partially it was that Muse on iPad vs macOS felt like two incomplete halves — can’t type on iPad, can’t ink on macOS. Partially: things I did in Muse, felt stuck in Muse; not literally true, but copy or export out of Obsidian vs Muse feels very different. Partially: always that nagging concern from lack of E2EE sync, and after Apple launched E2EE for iCloud, Obsidian + iCloud offered the sync I wanted with a subscription I already had anyhow. (Collaboration features aren’t as good, though!)

Anyhow. Muse did so many things well and first in this space, it remains impressive. Many iPad apps (in my opinion) are incrementally different versions of Apple Notes; Muse is a standout example that supports Apple Pencil as well as Apple first-party apps but targets a very substantially different use than drawing. Although I’m setting it aside, still optimistic about what this year will bring for Muse, and wishing the best to Adam Wulf!

discuss

order