top | item 40576340

Ask HN: Who Is the Feynman of 2024?

3 points| axg11 | 1 year ago

Who is today's Feynman? Someone making an outsized impact on science or engineering AND a brilliant teacher producing lasting materials.

8 comments

order

PaulHoule|1 year ago

Hard to say. The Feynman Lectures aren’t universally loved. Physics courses that used hem as a textbook lost a lot of students although I read them myself on the way to a physics PhD and enjoyed them.

In physics I think there is no opportunity in research to do what Feynman did. Sure Ed Witten is a smart guy and did some really cool math but he hasn’t done a single thing connected to experiments and quite possibly his work will never be confirmed.

I know a prof who is famous for his machine learning work who has written some undergrad textbooks that I was impressed with but someone who worked with him as a TA (and now teaches CS at a small Christian college) was not impressed with that prof’s commitment to education.

I’m sure people who have done important research (say in biomedicine) have written great textbooks and done research but I don’t know them my name.

FrankWilhoit|1 year ago

Under today's conditions, there are no incentives for such a person to emerge or to be rewarded. You might as well ask what happened to Bell Labs.

sky2224|1 year ago

What incentives used to be present that are no longer around now?