[semi]

>Just because you need an algorithm such as a specialized prompt to retrieve this memorized data, is also irrelevant.

I disagree. Granted I'm a layman and not a lawyer so I have no clue how the court feels. But I can certainly make very specialized algorithms to produce whatever output I want from whatever input I want, and that shouldn't let me declare any input as infringing on any rights.

For the reducto ad absurdum example: I demand everyone stops using spaces, using the algorithm 'remove a space and add my copyrighted text' it produces an identical copy of my copyrighted text.

For the less absurd example.. if I took any clean model without your copyrighted text, and brute forced prompts and settings until I produced your text, is your model violating the copyright or is my inputs?

[bckr]

Well, I think this is why it’s not settled yet. However, the law depends on many reasonability tests.