[itsdavesanders]

I keep seeing this argument pop up about “should Obama be prosecuted” like it’s some sort of “gotcha liberal!”

And as a liberal I think “hell YES he should be prosecuted!” The government shouldn’t just go around killing citizens without due process. I don’t care what letter is by their name.

[JamesBarney]

I think that is 99% true, with the exception of civilians who take up arms against the US.

Imagine the civil war if the union couldn't kill confederates.

[SahAssar]

> Imagine the civil war if the union couldn't kill confederates.

A full scale civil war really is an extraordinary case and is a lot more akin to a regular war than what we are talking about here.

I'm more afraid of someone declaring war on an abstract concept (like the "war on terror") and then using broad powers meant to be used in normal wars between states that have declared combatants than I am of a civil war.

[kelnos]

If we have a declared war between the US and the people (US citizens or otherwise) who are taking up arms against the US, then sure, attack away.

But otherwise, the only remedy should be judicial process against these people: arrests, trial, etc. Otherwise we have a term for it: extrajudicial killing.

Of course, Congress has given the executive branch weird war powers over the past few decades, so legally I'm sure they're in the clear, unfortunately.

[downWidOutaFite]

That's the appropriate patriotic response that you'd hope all Americans would give, especially those who have sworn to defend the constitution. But what I've come to realize is that a lot of Americans somehow see it as their patriotic duty to destroy the Federal government, and will support anything that will undermine it, including breaking the rule of law and a scorched earth attack on "liberals" that wish to uphold our form of government. This is the legacy of the Confederate grievance that is still very much alive today.

[vundercind]

I hear the same shit a lot. IRL, and in right wing media. “They don’t seem to get that if they can prosecute Trump, we can prosecute Biden and Hillary for [any of several shaky charges]”

No, no: we do get that. We just think that’s a good thing. If you have the evidence (you don’t, or we’d have seen, like, any of it at all) then by all means, prosecute the absolute shit out of them!