top | item 41000327

(no title)

doytch | 1 year ago

People put valuations on lives all the time in risk analysis and I've never seen a cost even close to $100m.

DOT puts it at 13.2m: https://www.transportation.gov/office-policy/transportation-...

discuss

order

tjohns|1 year ago

Factor in the PR impact on the entire space program given the public visibility.

We've never had an astronaut crew get stranded on the moon. though we got close with Apollo 13. If/when that happens for the first time, you'd better believe the entire planet will be paying attention.

Just the congressional inquiries alone will set the space program back by decades.

esalman|1 year ago

This. It seems average Americans, including average hn commenters, have their future outlook confined to the next fiscal quarter.

idiotsecant|1 year ago

Astronauts are very visible deaths for politicians whose currency is points in the polls. Having your photo not show up on the news next to a photo of a dead square-jawed captain america astronaut is probably worth 100m of other peoples money.

Rapzid|1 year ago

They wouldn't be "astronauts". They'd be cargo.

rvnx|1 year ago

Finding someone who agrees to go to the moon with a risk of 1 out 2 of dying, and 1 of 2 of becoming a historical hero is really doable.

Plenty of volunteers, and no need for 100M USD.

People go to war for less than 50K USD.

esalman|1 year ago

The city I'm from, there are people who'll kill for USD equivalent of $100. That does not mean we should encourage it.

talldatethrow|1 year ago

The odds of dying in a war are less than 1 in 2, and for joining the military in general it is far far less.

choilive|1 year ago

Thats for the average person - whats the cost to replace the average astronaut? I've seen estimates that it costs $15M just to train 1 astronaut, and the pool of qualified candidates is likely extremely small. I would figure a guess of $100M per astronaut is not unreasonable.