[FormerBandmate]

> "AI risk is a concern because less intelligent entities are not usually able to constrain the behavior of more intelligent entities" - A coarse and imperfect model indeed, but certainly a model based on observations of interactions in the real world.

Donald Trump was the president of the United States. FDR was a very smart man but Oppenheimer was smarter and FDR had him build the atomic bomb. This is just wrong, and ChatGPT is nowhere near as intelligent than a five year old (intelligence is not knowing facts)

[olddustytrail]

What is your definition of intelligence then?

ChatGPT is vastly more intelligent than most humans on any measure I can think of that existed before 2 years ago when suddenly people started trying to conflate intelligence with sentience.

[jfyi]

I love this game, I'll give one.

Intelligence: the ability and scale of capability to navigate a non-deterministic system.

I feel that doesn't help though.

[emtel]

I think this is a very bad refutation, but the point of my post is not to advance a particular argument, but to sort out what types of arguments have any hope of settling the matter at all.