top | item 41246704

(no title)

s0kr8s | 1 year ago

On an international level, there is a grand plan to ditch old Freudian categories like narcisissm, borderline, etc. in the upcoming ICD11.

There was never much evidence for such diagnostic categories, and I was told that if you look at notes from old proceedings of the DSM-III committee that their inclusion was an artifact of the political need to get buy-in from the then-powerful psychoanalytic groups at the time.

The ICD11 plan to have a single personality disorder bucket makes more sense to me. At its core, a personality disorder consists of a heavily reinforced and entrenched cluster of behavior that is significantly self-defeating and that actively resists common intervention strategies. From that perspective, you could either have endless personality disorder categories or a single category that summarizes the phenomenon.

[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9881116/

discuss

order

rendx|1 year ago

ICD11 is final and released (though not "adopted" in most countries yet?), so the restructuring is not a "plan" any more.

s0kr8s|1 year ago

The restructuring is not complete, though: a concession was granted to allow borderline personality disorder to remain for the time being due to industry concerns related to reimbursement, but the plan remains to ditch it eventually.