top | item 41294846

(no title)

neilknowsbest | 1 year ago

I'm curious about that quote. To my mind, we don't farm because we're trying to use land to "create energy", we farm because it produces food that humans demand in order to live. Is there some way to satisfy humans' need for food using solar panels? Is there a way of synthesizing consumable food using only electricity and ambient air, maybe add a bit of water, etc?

It just feels a bit silly to imply that the point of farming is to produce energy, in a general sense.

discuss

order

skybrian|1 year ago

Yeah, the comparison feels a little off, but you could make a direct comparison to producing ethanol from corn or sugar cane.

And historically, it is true that agriculture was the source of most wealth, including both food and energy. Consider growing hay -> feeding pack animals -> transportation. Also, using firewood to generate heat, large amounts of which were needed to for expensive processes like iron smelting. (Not to mention human labor.)

Nowadays it's the other way around, agriculture requires energy inputs for things like fertilizer.