[verditelabs]

Same, these are all great points that I find as well. LLMs have made me a way more productive programmer, but a lot of that is because I already was an alright programmer and know how to take advantage of the strengths and weaknesses of the LLM. I think your last bullet point is most poignant, using Claude 3.5 I've been able to do tons of GUI and web programming, things I absolutely despise and refuse to do if I'm writing code by hand.

I sort of understand some of the vitriol that I see on HN but it is incredibly overblown. I don't really get a lot of the criticisms. LLMs aren't deterministic? Neither are humans. LLMs write bugs they can't fix? So do humans. LLMs are only good at being junior programmer copy paste machines? So are lots of humans.

My current project is training an LLM to do superoptimization and it's working exceedingly well so far. If you asked anyone on hacker news if that's a good idea, they'd probably say no.