[romaniitedomum]

Honestly, this reads more like someone who wanted to use C# from the outset and needed to come up with reasons to justify it, rather than an honest comparison of a number of languages and platforms with a view to selecting the best fit for the problem domain. None of the listed reasons for choosing C# are unique to C# or its ecosystem. And some of them seem to have been discovered to be applicable only after the fact.

For instance, productivity is listed as the top reason, but his team only found C#/dotNET to be the most productive after using it. They didn't know it would be the most productive in advance. So it wasn't a reason for choosing that platform.

Other reasons listed are, 1 Open Source, 2. Cross Platform, 3. Popularity, 4. Memory Safety, 5. Garbage Collection, 6. Stability, 7. Statically-Typed, 8. Batteries Included, 9. Tooling, and 10. Performance. I think there are plenty of languages and platforms that are as good as C#/dotNET in all of these areas, but there's nothing here to suggest any of them were even considered.

[smashedtoatoms]

I'd have written this exact comment two years ago. After two years using C# and .NET in anger, I'd pick it for almost any project. It's better than Python, Ruby, Go, Elixir, Typescript, Etc. and better than Rust unless you absolutely must squeeze every ounce of performance out of something, and even then, sometimes C# is better.

I know it's not cool, but I spend very little time on distracting stupid shit in C#. No other ecosystem does it as well as .NET. It seems like such a low bar, yet almost no one can get over it.

I sit down to program for what feels like 30 minutes in a moment of inspiration, and I look up and it's been 5 hours and I got more done than I was expecting. Every other language often has me dealing with some distraction having nothing to do with the actual problem I'm hoping to solve, and sometimes robbing me of the desire to solve the problem at all.

Other languages drive me to mess with my editor config, because it's more fun than trying to convince my environment that a business problem is more important to solve than why some dependency that was importing fine a week ago is now broken. Other languages have me trying to get AI to build me something I've built before without typing any code. C# wants me to ship something quickly that works and it wants to help me do it. It's a remarkable ecosystem, and it makes it really hard to put up with the hoops the others make me jump through. 5/5, would .NET again.

[smashedtoatoms]

All that said, you .NET folks need to let your patterns die in a fire. Modern C# doesn't require any of this crap anymore. Use functions. They're great. The world of nouns is behind us.