So, for people who are paranoid about using the services that are designed for these sorts of sharing, like Dropbox, GDrive, GPhotos, and a million others? These theoretical people would suffer the frustrations of setting up and managing their own db for the added privacy? I wonder what they have in those photos and meeting notes that is so sensitive?
I don't use any of those services, though I used to use Dropbox for sharing family reunion photos with older relatives who didn't have the technical skills to do much more than click links to download photos. I am also not a potential user of Earthstar's product.
>I wonder what they have in those photos and meeting notes that is so sensitive?
As someone who is actively working on documenting my family history using photos, original copies and reproductions of official documents, old paper letters and copies of letters, I can say that the dominant reason that I do not use any of those "services that are designed for these sorts of sharing, like Dropbox, GDrive, GPhotos, and a million others" because none of the things that I am working with are any of anyone else's business.
Using many of those "services" grants perpetual ownership and license to use anywhere, forever to the service operator and should that service collapse for any reason their only asset is the contact info and personal data that their customers have chosen to entrust them with.
Frankly speaking here, I have been using computers for a long time and the most dominant recent trend among tech-bros has been to conjure an app or service to con people into paying SaaS fees even if they stop using the app or service. There are fewer apps available that can be bought as a pay once use it forever app.
I'm not interesting in playing anyone's con games and the software industry is full of them as many here note whenever someone does a new "Show HN" post. Oftentimes some of the first comments note for other interested parties that there is a requirement to give an email address to test the app or to register an account just to be able to see for ourselves what it does and whether it is truly useful.
I'm not interested in helping fund someone's second or third or fourth income stream when it requires handing control of something I own outright to a third party who will make every attempt to monetize every part of the transactional relationship that develops when a user registers an account.
I do not trust companies or individuals to have my best interests in mind when I am using their products or services.
Since the materials that my family members have collected and preserved for generations can't be replaced and we are not trying to write books or shoot films about any of the individuals who may have led interesting lives it is none of anyone else's business what the photos depict or what the documents tell us about how each branch of the tree connects to an individual's trunk.
The archive of the work I'm doing will be available to my family members. Some of them unfortunately use social media to keep in touch with friends and family. I can't control what they do with the results of my work but I can control everything up to the point where I distribute it and it's my decision to keep it all local on storage that I own and control.
The tone of your last sentence is accusatory and, like this last sentence of mine is out of place.
danjl|1 year ago
doodlebugging|1 year ago
>I wonder what they have in those photos and meeting notes that is so sensitive?
As someone who is actively working on documenting my family history using photos, original copies and reproductions of official documents, old paper letters and copies of letters, I can say that the dominant reason that I do not use any of those "services that are designed for these sorts of sharing, like Dropbox, GDrive, GPhotos, and a million others" because none of the things that I am working with are any of anyone else's business.
Using many of those "services" grants perpetual ownership and license to use anywhere, forever to the service operator and should that service collapse for any reason their only asset is the contact info and personal data that their customers have chosen to entrust them with.
Frankly speaking here, I have been using computers for a long time and the most dominant recent trend among tech-bros has been to conjure an app or service to con people into paying SaaS fees even if they stop using the app or service. There are fewer apps available that can be bought as a pay once use it forever app.
I'm not interesting in playing anyone's con games and the software industry is full of them as many here note whenever someone does a new "Show HN" post. Oftentimes some of the first comments note for other interested parties that there is a requirement to give an email address to test the app or to register an account just to be able to see for ourselves what it does and whether it is truly useful.
I'm not interested in helping fund someone's second or third or fourth income stream when it requires handing control of something I own outright to a third party who will make every attempt to monetize every part of the transactional relationship that develops when a user registers an account.
I do not trust companies or individuals to have my best interests in mind when I am using their products or services.
Since the materials that my family members have collected and preserved for generations can't be replaced and we are not trying to write books or shoot films about any of the individuals who may have led interesting lives it is none of anyone else's business what the photos depict or what the documents tell us about how each branch of the tree connects to an individual's trunk.
The archive of the work I'm doing will be available to my family members. Some of them unfortunately use social media to keep in touch with friends and family. I can't control what they do with the results of my work but I can control everything up to the point where I distribute it and it's my decision to keep it all local on storage that I own and control.
The tone of your last sentence is accusatory and, like this last sentence of mine is out of place.