A bookmarklet to kill sticky headers (2013)

[ashtonmeuser]

Bookmarklet aficionado and maintainer of bookmarkl.ink here. Took the liberty of posting this bookmarklet: https://bookmarkl.ink/ashtonmeuser/849a972686e1505093c6d4fc5...

[stevage]

Wow, the Doom bookmarklet is kind of cool. https://bookmarkl.ink/ashtonmeuser/04710d3befc446e849108a587...

It seems there isn't a way to browse existing bookmarklets, other than the small, curated lists?

[RheingoldRiver]

I have a couple bookmarklets scattered in a couple blog posts that you may find interesting / want to add:

* https://river.me/blog/bookmarklet-stay-here/

* https://river.me/blog/firefox-keep-bookmark-keywords/

* https://river.me/blog/url-bar-is-a-cli/

[m0d0nne11]

Aficionados will appreciate Jesse Ruderman's bookmarklets at https://www.squarefree.com/bookmarklets/ which have been saving my sanity since the early 2000s.

[vidyesh]

I love this project! I used to use a lot of bookmarklets, but lost a lot of them and couldn't find all I used to use. Is it possible for you to create a directory or listing for all the hosted bookmarklets, but that might need curation too.

[quickslowdown]

Nice, this is very cool, thanks for the work & for sharing :)

[crazygringo]

I've been using the Kill-Sticky Chrome extension for years:

https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/kill-sticky/lekjlgf...

Because it has a configurable keyboard shortcut.

Can't imagine browsing the web without it. At this point hitting Cmd+K when I visit an article is pure reflex.

A bookmarklet would be more secure, but I don't know of a way to assign keyboard shortcuts to one.

[Noumenon72]

You can add a Chrome site shortcut whose URL is a bookmarklet, so it will run the bookmarklet when you type "bm" in the address bar (for example).

Taking it even further so it will run with just one keystroke, on my Mac I used Karabiner to run a terminal script that types the bookmarklet in the address bar for me:

    tell application "System Events"
        keystroke "l" using {command down} -- Select the address bar (Cmd+L)
        keystroke "bm" -- Type "bm"
        delay 0.2  # Let Chrome recognize the site shortcut
        keystroke return -- Press Enter
    end tell

In my script I open a new Chrome window before this because the bookmarklet submits a nag screen from my job, but for stickies you could have it just switch back to the window you're reading instead.

[aeromusek]

Chrome bookmarks also show up as items in the Bookmarks menu, which means you can use the built-in macOS functionality to assign your own custom keyboard shortcuts in System Preferences → Keyboard.

[gabrielsroka]

> more secure

interesting. that extension's Support section has a link to https://github.com/eemeli/chrome-kill-sticky whose license is MIT, so you could make your own extension. That repo also has a newer version of the code, and that was deployed on the Firefox store, but not on the Chrome store.

[bschne]

Anecdote: I was in charge of a complete rebuild for an e-commerce website a few years back, which included a new design. We were debating various layout options, as it was tricky to get the information hierarchy right and show everything necessary even on smaller screens. Then we had an internal review and the CEO complicated things considerably by insisting it was very important that the header be sticky --- to ensure that the company logo would always remain visible even when scrolling, reminding users of our brand.

[eviks]

Is it possible to distract the kid in power with a favicon that is always visible in the url bar and allow users not curse the brand due to stickiness?

[stalfosknight]

CEOs need to be stopped or at least be told to shut the fuck up.

[mrweasel]

It continues to amaze me how many companies believe that customer care about their brand. The brands people care the most about are yet those they actively attempt to avoid, or those who doesn't need to constantly remind people of their existence.

[quantadev]

The whole entire internet is broken.

Specifically what I mean is HTML is flawed. It should never have been a presentation format. It should've always been a DATA format, like JSON, or XML, from day one. The browser itself would then be able to display information (pages) in whatever style, colors, and format it wants.

Probably 99.999% of developers agree with this, but we're stuck in a RUT it seems. I know what I'm sort of talking about is the "Semantic Web", and I'm probably preaching to the choir to bring it up on Hacker News.

But I'm wondering if it's possible to change? What would it take? We'd need some major movement, almost like Web3, or Blockchains, that got everyone to wake up and realize there's an easier way. We're stuck because there's no real incentive for change. It's a chicken and egg problem. No one is gonna be first to design something, unless everyone else is already using it. :( Thanks for listening. That was step one I guess.

[crazygringo]

Almost nobody wants that though.

Content providers want control over presentation.

Users want pretty sites.

None of this is unique to the web. It's the same reason every magazine has its own attractive layout and formatting, instead of just being a long manuscript in Courier.

I like the fact that different sites have different typography. It's an identity that tells me where I am.

I understand the appeal of "pure information" without any visual variation ever, but I think that for most people, variety is the spice of life, no?

I wouldn't want every site to look the same, for the same reason I wouldn't want everyone to dress like clones. Visual self-expression is part of what it is to be alive.

[carlosjobim]

It's already been solved and it's called reader view.

[nfriedly]

I'm using the Bar Breaker Firefox Extension[1], it's particularly helpful on Android devices with smaller screens.

It completely gets rid of the bars, which is sometimes great, but sometimes too much. I occasionally have to turn it off for workflows where the "next" button is in a fixed bar, such as checkout for US Mobile, or saving a Yoto playlist.

[1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bar-breaker/

[layer8]

> There's even a sticky header web startup.

That’s hilarious (and sad). It seems to be still in business, since 2012.

[nejsjsjsbsb]

Surprisingly that site has no sticky header. It did trigger a Google login attempt and ask for notification permissions plus had a couple of sticky buttons at the bottom.

[burgerrito]

uBlock Origin blocked the website. Gee, I wonder why

[DaveSwift]

Love it! Since it's now 2025, we probably should search for "fixed" & "sticky"

Here's a minified version with "sticky" added:

javascript:(()=>[...document.querySelectorAll('body *')].map(el=>["fixed","sticky"].includes(getComputedStyle(el).position)&&el.remove()))();

[gabrielsroka]

even more minified. forEach doesn't return anything, so you don't need the IIFE.

  javascript:document.querySelectorAll('body *').forEach(el=>['fixed','sticky'].includes(getComputedStyle(el).position)&&el.remove())

or

  javascript:document.querySelectorAll('body *').forEach(el=>/^(fixed|sticky)$/.test(getComputedStyle(el).position)&&el.remove())

[evgpbfhnr]

Interestingly running this in the console works but from a bookmarklet changes all the page content to false,false,false,.... (on firefox)

Any idea?

[lasarkolja]

Dont hate me, but I would like to have the opposite functionality

Just for mobile, where it is very annoying on long pages (Laravel Docs for example) to scroll up just to get the menue button.

[skydhash]

If you’re on ios, you can tap the clock for fast scroll up.

[lucasluitjes]

Here you go: javascript:(function(){window.scrollTo({top:0,behavior:'smooth'});})();

[miramba]

Same here, and I want the sticky Safari bottom tool bar back! Why is that not configurable?

[chrsw]

These things are so annoying. Is there a website benchmark not for speed, not for security but for "annoyingness"? I guess there is some overlap with accessibility, but that's not exactly what I'm thinking of.

I asked Copilot and searched Google but couldn't really come up with anything.

[kevindamm]

It is the inverse of what engagement is supposed to be measuring, but it turns out that optimizing for engagement takes you down a darker path...

[nightpool]

CLS was roughly designed to measure annoyingness in terms of "moving layout elements". I'm sure Google has even more nuanced signals to measure e.g. ad coverage vs content coverage

[shiomiru]

In my text browser I came up with a way to implement these that doesn't move boxes around the page.[0] In short: treat "position: fixed" as an absolute child of the root box, and ignore "position: sticky" (mostly).

This doesn't completely eliminate sticky headers/footers (problematic when you actually want to use them), but they behave like normal elements at the start/end of the page (instead of the screen).

I initially did it this way for technical reasons, but now I kind of prefer it to what mainstream browsers do.

[0]: https://git.sr.ht/~bptato/chawan/tree/e56399f92d2323f9af95e0... (not a great explanation - it says "bottom", but like "position: absolute" it's placed at the top if only "top" is specified, etc.)

[fatboy]

I have a (badly made) variant of kill sticky that I use on my phone. It kills sticky, then messes with any code blocks it finds to make them full width and use a smaller font.

It drives me mad when I'm reading articles with embedded code blocks where the code has less room than the prose and sometimes a bigger font!

It works well on eg this page (https://www.programiz.com/swift-programming/inheritance), but maybe someone that knows what they're doing can make it work on GitHub. It'd be nice to not see those line numbers taking up half the width.

I'm on my phone so I've only the bookmarklet to hand:

   javascript:(function()%7Bvar%20i%3Bvar%20b%3Ddocument.querySelectorAll(%22body%20*%22)%3Bfor(i%3D0%3Bi%3Cb.length%3Bi%2B%2B)%7Bvar%20el%3Db%5Bi%5D%3Bif(getComputedStyle(el).position.match(%2Ffixed%7Csticky%2Fgi))%7Bel.parentNode.removeChild(el)%3B%7D%7Dconst%20c%3Ddocument.querySelectorAll(%22html%22)%3Bfor(i%3D0%3Bi%3Cc.length%3Bi%2B%2B)%7Bif(%22hidden%22%3D%3D%3DgetComputedStyle(c%5Bi%5D).overflow)%7Bc%5Bi%5D.style.setProperty('overflow'%2C%22scroll%22%2C%22important%22)%3B%7D%7D%7D)()%3B(function()%7Bvar%20i%2Cj%2Cb%3Ddocument.querySelectorAll(%22pre%22)%3Bfunction%20setPropertiesOuter(el)%7Bel.style.setProperty('margin-left'%2C%22calc(-50vw%20%2B%2050%25)%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('margin-right'%2C%22calc(-50vw%20%2B%2050%25)%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('font-size'%2C%2211px%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('text-indent'%2C%220%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('border-left-width'%2C%220%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('border-right-width'%2C%220%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('border-radius'%2C%220%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('padding'%2C%2210px%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('width'%2C%22100vw%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('max-width'%2C%22100vw%22%2C%22important%22)%3B%7Dfunction%20setPropertiesInner(el)%7Bel.style.setProperty('font-size'%2C%2211px%22%2C%22important%22)%3Bel.style.setProperty('text-indent'%2C%220%22%2C%22important%22)%7Dfor(i%3D0%3Bi%3Cb.length%3Bi%2B%2B)%7Bconst%20el%3Db%5Bi%5D%3BsetPropertiesOuter(el)%3Bvar%20descendants%3Del.querySelectorAll(%22*%22)%3Bfor(j%3D0%3Bj%3Cdescendants.length%3Bj%2B%2B)%7BsetPropertiesInner(descendants%5Bj%5D)%7D%7D%7D)()

[lemonberry]

The only sticky headers I like are the ones that disappear while scrolling to the bottom of the page but reappear when scrolling back up. Preferably while scrolling up the user is only seeing the navigation and logo. Otherwise, they're super annoying.

[eviks]

These are just as bad, at least their default implementation that triggers on tiny up movements as it covers content you tried to re-read or just annoyingly pops up on inadvertent finger movements

[mlekoszek]

Unless you're reading at the top of the screen (i.e. on a phone), scroll up to recap on something you missed, and then the header slides in and covers the exact thing you were trying to read.

Bonus points if the header is absolutely massive and takes up a full fifth of the innerHeight.

[bloopernova]

Is there a way to get this working on Firefox Android?

The bluesky sticky header is annoying, and I haven't seen a way to just switch it off.

EDIT: solved: drag kill sticky to bookmarks on desktop browser, then access bookmark from sync'd Firefox on Android.

[wonger_]

There's another way! Instructions: https://paul.kinlan.me/use-bookmarklets-on-chrome-on-android... Summary:

  1. bookmark any page
  2. change the url to your code
  3. give it a title like !script
  4. to activate, tap the address bar and type !script

Works on Android Chrome and Firefox, and probably other browsers too. More people ought to know about mobile bookmarklets.

[evgpbfhnr]

If someone has one for the "share this" popups when you select some text in way too many articles/blogs I'd love to add this to my collection...

[codingrightnow]

He can't hate them that much he put one on his website.

[urbandw311er]

I think that’s kind of the point. He puts a button just down from the top that kills it.

[al_borland]

I saw this as a feature. I was able to click the button and make it go away, to see it work.

[Forge36]

It makes for a good test

[nejsjsjsbsb]

That's called irony.

[username223]

A "kill-fixed" bookmarklet that kills anything with position "fixed" or "sticky" is essential to making websites usable. The "best" is Substack, where I load the page with JavaScript disabled, then enable it to kill the red fixed-position bar telling me that JavaScript is essential.

[ggasp]

Perfect little tool I’ve been using but I completely forgot.

I make it a Shortcut out of it: https://www.icloud.com/shortcuts/8aa788a3acc747169a6d80191a0...

[tempodox]

Nowadays even more vital than 12 years ago. Things have not gotten better in the meantime.

I've been using the Kill Sticky bookmarklet for that:

https://github.com/t-mart/kill-sticky.git

[stevage]

So it works by removing elements with "position: fixed".

But do all sticky headers work like that? In sites that I build, I tend to just have a normal div at the top, followed by a div for the main body with "overflow-y: scroll".

[chrismorgan]

Please don't implement things like that: among one or two other related problems, it breaks keyboard navigability, because the document then isn't scrollable. So users have to focus your div by clicking or tabbing to it before things like Space to go down one pageful will work.

`position: sticky` or `fixed` are the only acceptable techniques to implement sticky headers for typical websites. (There are definitely app scenarios where you need multiple scroll areas and don't want any of them to use the document scroll area, e.g. a multi-pane email client; in such cases you should then manage focus just a little so one pane gets focus when everything loses it.)

[SeanAnderson]

This article is about removing all fixed elements on a page. Not only do other elements catch strays, fixed isn't the industry standard way of making sticky headers in 2025!

[dredmorbius]

Fixed isn't the industry standard way of making sticky headers in 2025

What is? Flexbox? Or something else?

(Not a FE dev, though I'm vaguely conversant in CSS, mostly by using it to fix site annoyances on my own via stylesheet management extensions such as Stylus.)

[mrzool]

I still use this daily.

[perching_aix]

the website has a massive, undismissing sticky header on top on mobile with js disabled. it's also the useless kind. rather ironic.

[err4nt]

Presumably so you can test it on-page

[zoom6628]

Kill Sticky is brilliant. Been using for years.

[bradgessler]

If only sticky headers didn’t convert so well!

[carlosjobim]

Convert to what? Not to actual sales for sure. But maybe converting well to annoying and confusing the potential customer, which seems to be much more important than making sales.

[zapkyeskrill]

2025 and it still works, even on mobile

[fn-mote]

(2013) but I will give it a try.

[cuttysnark]

Since then we've gotten: position: sticky — which is like fixed but only "fixes" itself once its Y offset is satisfied. Updating the bookmarklet to also check for that, in addition to position: fixed would help modernize it a bit.