top | item 42931527

(no title)

mimsee | 1 year ago

Are IP addresses considered PII or not? I remember there being multiple conflicting conclusions on that

discuss

order

sdefresne|1 year ago

It looks like IP addresses are considered PII by GDPR:

https://gdpr.eu/eu-gdpr-personal-data/

They are explicitly listed as example of PII.

cmenge|1 year ago

So in essence, it disallows logging IP address for any purpose, be it security, debugging, rate-limiting etc. because you can't give consent in advance for this, and no other sentence in Art. 6.1 applies.

Moreover, to reason about this, one also needs to take into account Art 6.2 which means there might be an additional 27 laws you need to find and understand.

Note, however, that recital 30 which you quoted is explicitly NOT referenced by Art. 6, at least according to this inofficial site: https://gdpr-info.eu/art-6-gdpr/

This particular case might be solved through hashing, but then there are only 4.2bn IPs so easy to try out all hashes. Or maybe it's only OK with IPv6?

I find this vague or at least hard to reconcile with technical everyday reality, and doing it well can take enormous amounts of time and money that are not spent on advancing anything of value.