top | item 42980097

Why gold loves arsenic (2021)

52 points| DoreenMichele | 1 year ago |mining.com

27 comments

order

ggm|1 year ago

Having panned for gold in Gympie I was convinced I'd come home with a lot of pyrites and now 30 years later I feel I need to revisit that tiny jar of yellow dust.

(Got a killer dose of sunburn just above the bum crack bending over in the stream with my pan, a reminder sunscreen has to go EVERYWHERE.)

stavros|1 year ago

Not everywhere, just everywhere the sun shines.

memorydial|1 year ago

Fascinating read! So if arsenic helps gold concentrate in deposits, does this mean arsenic-rich environments are better places to prospect? Or is it more about how existing deposits form rather than finding new ones?

fjjjrjj|1 year ago

It loves mercury too which is also toxic. Interesting.

zdragnar|1 year ago

Mercury loves lots of metals. NileRed has some fantastic videos playing around with the stuff on YouTube

ggm|1 year ago

But mercury-gold amalgam, maybe different chemistry at play?

refurb|1 year ago

It also loves cyanide. Which is why it's used to leach gold in mining.

metalman|1 year ago

quick search on "arsenic in water" yields endless official governmental and other notices all over the world, so there does not apear to be a direct asosiation between (recoverable) gold and arsenic and that it is so prevelant that some humans have adapted and pass arsenic. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/centuries-poison-l...

OutOfHere|1 year ago

So what you are saying is that fool's gold isn't totally foolish.

memorydial|1 year ago

Right? Turns out fool’s gold has a bit of wisdom after all. It won’t make you rich, but in the right conditions, it can help concentrate the real stuff!

kazinator|1 year ago

If you have lots of gold, have your food tested for arsenic.

zaik|1 year ago

Or don't put gold in your food?

labster|1 year ago

With this sympathy between gold and arsenic discovered, we’re one step closer to the philosopher’s stone.

Terr_|1 year ago

Thales of Miletus already made one, but it turned out to just be water.

flashfaffe2|1 year ago

Genuine question for an outsider: would this imply that gold can be created? My memories from the last chemistry class I had, I clearly remember my teacher demonstrating philosopher stone ( aka changing materials in gold ) was feasible.

somebodynew|1 year ago

This article is about arsenic minerals acting like a sponge that holds and concentrates gold from the surrounding environment that it comes in contact with. It isn't creating new atoms of gold.

Gold can be created through an unrelated process of nuclear transmutation, but it's impractically expensive [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthesis_of_precious_metals#G...

gruturo|1 year ago

Gold is a chemical element, not an alloy or any kind of mixture of other things - so no, chemical reactions won't help you get gold.

Nuclear reactions WILL produce gold - in many ways actually (none profitable afaik):

- throw a neutron or 2 at neighboring elements, ensure they have the right energy for the cross section, hopefully with neutron capture and beta decay you get some gold (maybe the stable Au197 version, maybe a violently radioactive isotope though, I wouldn't wear a ring made of that. And it will eventually stop being gold when it decays). Oh an immense amount of radioactive byproducts. And the starting elements are often more expensive than gold itself.

- Fuse 2 lighter elements with just the right weights, you may get gold. But creating elements above iron is energy-negative so your fusion reaction will immediately die unless you can sustain it. All the gold we found on the planet was created during supernovas IIRC.

- Fission something heavier and hope that gold is one of the pieces you're left with.

- Start with an unstable isotope of Thallium, Bismuth, etc and hope for a few alpha decays to line up and get you gold.

There are actually quite a few paths.... and ALL the gold you'll ever see, whether artificial or "natural", was created with one or another (but most really is from supernovas). Remember, we started with only the building blocks in the big bang, mostly Hydrogen.

memorydial|1 year ago

Nope, this doesn’t create gold, just helps existing gold accumulate in certain conditions. Actual gold creation requires nuclear reactions, which are technically possible but not practical.

Tuna-Fish|1 year ago

A fun little fact: We now have the ability that alchemists sought for so long (transmuting elements through nuclear reactions), and we are using it to destroy gold, not create it.

The processes involved are so expensive to do that in terms of cost it doesn't really matter what you are using as the source material, and the way gold is very resistant to corrosion is useful for using as a target in experiments.