First of all, the way CDC works, it's just a board of directors from many pharmaceutical corporations. There are known conflicts of interest here.
Secondly, USA is considered a very unhealthy in comparison to Europe and other countries, while that's mosrly related to FDA, CDC also plays a role here by promoting drugs/vaccines in cases you only need a change of habits (like eating well to minimize flu severity)
Third, the way CDC dealt with COVID was unacceptable, their mixed messages about facemask, social distancing, herd immunity, reapiratory machines caused many people to die, and not because of the virus necessarily. This is a 15k people agency.
And worth to mention their controversy to require social media companies to censor posts about Wuhan Institute of Virology, when we all know today it was true, and CDC was partially responsible of the COVID 19 crisis. Also their censorship of scientists who disagreed with CDC conclusions, and some of them resulted to be factual.
After all of this, I do think it's fair to reform the CDC entirely. The economic impacts of their mistakes destroyed millions of business and caused many people unemployed. Even today 2025 you see few large companies struggling or going bankrupt because of their debt under COVID.
You may think we had to do that to prevent COVID spread, but all current data says the opposite, and many countries who never took hard measures had same or lower spread than US. CDC had to rectify all of their errors.
I have many friends who lost their jobs, VISA or green card process, because CDC was incompetent to act against a virus they previously knew, and recommended things they didn't encourage in the past (like paper/cloth masks to prevent spread of a viral virus).
> CDC also plays a role here by promoting drugs/vaccines in cases you only need a change of habits (like eating well to minimize flu severity)
What fields of medicine did you specialize in?
I find it puzzling that there are people out there like you who want to dismantle public health infrastructure when we have active outbreaks of measles, bird flu and who knows what else.
I'm all for improving and optimizing public health services (or all government services for that matter) but I don't understand this willingness to threaten people's safety. Does Google just take down their search engine when they want to merge in a PR?
You're pushing a conspiracy constructed in pursuit of a narrative.
No, the CDC did not knowingly assist in creating and spreading COVID to kill people across the globe. It caught everyone off guard and the world was woefully underprepared to handle such an event. A million Americans died and people still call the entire thing a hoax and demand blood from public officials like Fauci.
Maybe, just maybe, if people listened to the CDC and WHO we would have better outcomes. Maybe if we acted earlier, like was requested, we would have prevented it's spread. But I seem to recall a certain set of executive and legislative members doing everything they could to politicize and antagonize and encourage the use of ineffective dewormers.
And when we finally made a vaccine, those very people discouraged it's use to the extreme - conspiracies of microchips galore - and had public health officials getting death threats. But, no, it's the CDC's fault.
I won't even touch how utterly asinine the "just eat better and let everyone get the flu" comment is.
waltercool|1 year ago
Secondly, USA is considered a very unhealthy in comparison to Europe and other countries, while that's mosrly related to FDA, CDC also plays a role here by promoting drugs/vaccines in cases you only need a change of habits (like eating well to minimize flu severity)
Third, the way CDC dealt with COVID was unacceptable, their mixed messages about facemask, social distancing, herd immunity, reapiratory machines caused many people to die, and not because of the virus necessarily. This is a 15k people agency.
And worth to mention their controversy to require social media companies to censor posts about Wuhan Institute of Virology, when we all know today it was true, and CDC was partially responsible of the COVID 19 crisis. Also their censorship of scientists who disagreed with CDC conclusions, and some of them resulted to be factual.
After all of this, I do think it's fair to reform the CDC entirely. The economic impacts of their mistakes destroyed millions of business and caused many people unemployed. Even today 2025 you see few large companies struggling or going bankrupt because of their debt under COVID.
You may think we had to do that to prevent COVID spread, but all current data says the opposite, and many countries who never took hard measures had same or lower spread than US. CDC had to rectify all of their errors.
I have many friends who lost their jobs, VISA or green card process, because CDC was incompetent to act against a virus they previously knew, and recommended things they didn't encourage in the past (like paper/cloth masks to prevent spread of a viral virus).
basementcat|1 year ago
> First of all, the way CDC works, it's just a board of directors from many pharmaceutical corporations.
Citation needed. This is very much as odds with what is described at
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centers_for_Disease_Control_an...
> CDC also plays a role here by promoting drugs/vaccines in cases you only need a change of habits (like eating well to minimize flu severity)
What fields of medicine did you specialize in?
I find it puzzling that there are people out there like you who want to dismantle public health infrastructure when we have active outbreaks of measles, bird flu and who knows what else.
I'm all for improving and optimizing public health services (or all government services for that matter) but I don't understand this willingness to threaten people's safety. Does Google just take down their search engine when they want to merge in a PR?
Tadpole9181|1 year ago
No, the CDC did not knowingly assist in creating and spreading COVID to kill people across the globe. It caught everyone off guard and the world was woefully underprepared to handle such an event. A million Americans died and people still call the entire thing a hoax and demand blood from public officials like Fauci.
Maybe, just maybe, if people listened to the CDC and WHO we would have better outcomes. Maybe if we acted earlier, like was requested, we would have prevented it's spread. But I seem to recall a certain set of executive and legislative members doing everything they could to politicize and antagonize and encourage the use of ineffective dewormers.
And when we finally made a vaccine, those very people discouraged it's use to the extreme - conspiracies of microchips galore - and had public health officials getting death threats. But, no, it's the CDC's fault.
I won't even touch how utterly asinine the "just eat better and let everyone get the flu" comment is.