top | item 43350045

(no title)

_fs | 11 months ago

Its completely obvious that a bot army is gaming the system. Posts are flagged within minutes of posting

discuss

order

swatcoder|11 months ago

That's not obvious at all.

People refresh all day here and often on the new post and new and comment feeds specifically, and many earnest users who take pride in maintaining a certain character to the site are quick to flag anything that's likely to devolve into noise and vitriol, like most political topics.

It can be frustrating to have them do that when you really wish you could to commiserate, explore, or debate the community on these topics, but bots aren't at play. Many people just don't see this as the right place to have these discussions and work to keep it that way.

While almost all of are political in some way, and most of us are tracking all these same events, we don't all want talk about it here.

oooyay|11 months ago

I really wish people, widely, would stop blaming bots. I am sure there are plenty of bots doing lots of things, but by immediately attributing this behavior to bots I think we detach ourselves from a fundamental fact: there are a lot of US citizens that are so far drowning in propaganda that they actually manufacture reason for much of this insanity without much provocation or incentive beyond it being done by their tribe.

throwawa14223|11 months ago

I am in the habit of flagging anything related to American politics. It never leads anywhere and seems orthogonal to HN.

_fs|11 months ago

Yea, I got tired of people attempting to make comments like this and wrote a script to quickly analyze past comment history to see if they were truly being honest.

You have consistently and reliably posted your political views here. Please don't try to pretend that you hate the political discourse now that people are critical of your guy.

ggm|11 months ago

I am a regular on HN and I disagree. So, do we cancel each other out?

ryandrake|11 months ago

"Political" is not a binary true or false. There are plenty of on-topic articles here that merely have "political overlap" as dang[1] puts it, and they should not be flagged. To be fair, this article seems to be more towards the "purely political" side of the spectrum and was probably correctly flagged.

I think this rule is generally followed by HN's users, but for whatever reason, anything that touches "Elon" or "DOGE" always gets insta-buried, whether or not it's tech-related, whether or not it's interesting, whether or not it's worth discussing.

I don't think it's automated bots, but there is most certainly an online Elon Defense Brigade of real users out there trying to bury anything negative about the guy. I don't know what would make someone devote so much time to defending the honor of a billionaire. It's almost religious.

1: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...