[halfadot]

>The hypothetical is irrelevant here; what is germane is that the expectation of privacy by the individual participants, and the terms which bind people who use that service.

How can you have an expectation of privacy in a public forum? Where did this bizarre disorder originate, where people knowingly put their writing out there for literally anyone to read, then turn around and start talking about "expectations of privacy" when they realize what it entails?

[AStonesThrow]

> Where did this bizarre disorder originate

Well unfortunately it originated in the human condition, my friend.

I take it back about "expectation of privacy". Perhaps that is an outmoded concept.

Humans used to sort of have a default expectation of privacy. Being that gossip, slander and libel were sins and crimes, we could often safely gather in a room and isolate ourselves in a select group, and share our thoughts openly.

Most humans could go into a living room with their family, a pub or bar, a classroom, or a treehouse, and say/do things that were shared only by the local group of gathered humans. You could go into a public park and speak to a fire hydrant. It was not usual, or possible 100 years ago, for the news media to go around with recorders and cameras and record/preserve/transmit/broadcast everything everyone said in every place they were doing it.

Expectations of privacy were just sort of... humankind's default setting. And so betrayals were sins and crimes. And we sit alone at our keyboard looking at a screen. It feels private, all right. Where are we really? Where are our words being carried? We can't know anymore.

Unfortunately we've built online and virtual worlds around paradigms that imply privacy or confidentiality, but don't actually afford it. You can go into a "chat room" or a "forum" or change your "privacy settings" but they mean nothing. Nothing at all. Because everything we're sending across the net can be perfectly recorded, preserved, retransmitted, and it's no longer gossip, it's just business.

> Where did this bizarre disorder originate

I don't believe that any other living organism has had to deal with the complete and total collapse of "privacy" like humans in the 21st century. Surely, termites in Australia don't know, and couldn't care, about what's going on with honeybees in California.

And here we have people calling it a bizarre disorder. Yes, it's mistaken and misguided, but who can call it unreasonable?