top | item 44074013

(no title)

Aidevah | 9 months ago

> Universalism: that is the intellectual realm abutting utopianism and ethnocentrism. "There are universal values, and they happen to be mine," was Stanley Hoffman’s delightful definition of the latter. Like utopianism and ethnocentrism, universalism normalizes, excludes, and shouts down. If “universal” does not mean universally accepted, then it means nothing. Those who do not accept must therefore at least be marginalized, and if possible stigmatized.

-- Richard Taruskin [1]

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/1995/09/10/arts/the-new-seasonclassi...

discuss

order

cm2012|9 months ago

Yes, for instance, I think its fine if people who support hurting other innocent people are marginalized.

defen|9 months ago

That doesn't actually solve the problem, it simply moves the debate into what constitutes innocence and hurting.