top | item 44147810

Show HN: Tracking Merged PRs by OpenAI's Codex and GitHub's Copilot

6 points| zekone | 9 months ago |github.com

Figured I'd track the popular coding agents to see merge and approval rates. At first I was tracking Opened vs. Approved, but realized most people aren't approving; they just merge.

I haven't found a way to reliably track the other agents (Jules, Devin, etc), since they don't have a standardized branch naming convention. Interesting to watch this over time. Open to ideas.

2 comments

[+] mutant|9 months ago|reply

Thats a pretty cool repo. Curious, have you tried Codex? I thought it was awful. At least compared to Cline, claude code, and goose.

It makes me wonder about those commits…

[+] zekone|9 months ago|reply

Codex UX is wonky. if it makes changes for you and you create a PR with it; then have follow interactions to further modify, it will result in a new PR for every subsequent change. it doesn't update or modify an existing PR.

Copilot does. which is maybe why its numbers are lower; but I prefer this interaction more