top | item 44199509

(no title)

molf | 8 months ago

It would help tremendously if OpenAI would make it possible to apply for zero data retention (ZDR). For many business needs there is no reason to store or log any request at all.

In theory it is possible to apply (it's mentioned on multiple locations in the documentation), but in practice requests are just being ignored. I get that approval needs to be given, and that there are barriers to entry. But it seems to me they mention zero-data retention only for marketing purposes.

We have applied multiple times and have yet to receive ANY response. Reading through the forums this seems very common.

discuss

order

miles|8 months ago

> I get that approval needs to be given, and that there are barriers to entry.

Why is approval necessary, and what specific barriers (before the latest ruling) prevent privacy and no logging from being the default?

OpenAI’s assurances have long been met with skepticism by many, with the assumption that inputs are retained, analyzed, and potentially shared. For those concerned with genuine privacy, local LLMs remain essential.

AlecSchueler|8 months ago

> what specific barriers (before the latest ruling) prevent privacy and no logging from being the default?

Product development?

ArnoVW|8 months ago

My understanding is that they log 30 days by default, for handling of bugs. And that you can request 0 days. This is from their documentation

lcnPylGDnU4H9OF|8 months ago

> And that you can request 0 days.

Right but the problem they're having is that the request is ignored.

pclmulqdq|8 months ago

The missing ingredient is money.

jewelry|8 months ago

not just money. How are you going to support this client’s support ticket if there is no log at all?

belter|8 months ago

If this stands I dont think they can operate in the EU

bunderbunder|8 months ago

I highly doubt this court order affects people using OpenAI services from the EU, as long as they're connecting to EU-based servers.

1vuio0pswjnm7|8 months ago

"You can also request zero data retention (ZDR) for eligible endpoints if you have a qualifying use-case. For details on data handling, visit our Platform Docs page."

https://openai.com/en-GB/policies/row-privacy-policy/

1. You can request it but there is no promise the request will be granted.

Defaults matter. Silicon Valley's defaults are not designed for privacy. They are designed for profit. OpenAI's default is retention. Outputs are saved by default.

It is difficult to take the arguments in their memo ISO objection to the preservation order seriously. OpenAI already preserves outputs by default.

lmm|8 months ago

> In theory it is possible to apply (it's mentioned on multiple locations in the documentation), but in practice requests are just being ignored. I get that approval needs to be given, and that there are barriers to entry. But it seems to me they mention zero-data retention only for marketing purposes.

What's the betting that they just write it on the website and never actually implemented it?

sigmoid10|8 months ago

Tbf the approach seems pretty standard. Azure also only offers zero retention to vetted customers and otherwise retains data for up to 30 days to monitor and detect abuse. Since the possibilities for abuse are so high with these models, it would make sense that they don't simply give that kind of privilege to everyone - if only to cover their own legal position.