[dowager_dan99]

>> an amazing tool to support learning, when used properly.

how can kids, think K-12, who don't even know how to "use" the internet properly - or even their phones - learn how to learn with AI? The same way social media and mobile apps made the internet easy, mindless clicking, LLMs make school a mechanical task. It feels like your argument is similar to LLMs helping experienced, senior developers code more effectively, while eliminating many chances to grow the skills needed to join that group. Sounds like you already know how to learn and use AI to enhance that. My 12-yr-old is not there yet and may never get there.

[lonelyasacloud]

>> how can kids, think K-12, who don't even know how to "use" the internet properly - or even their phones - learn how to learn with AI?

For every person/child that just wants the answer there will be at least some that will want to know why. And these endlessly patient machines are very good at feeding that curiosity.

[jplusequalt]

>For every person/child that just wants the answer there will be at least some that will want to know why

You're correct, but let's be honest here, the majority will use it as a means to get their homework over and done with so they can return to Tik Tok. Is that the society we want to cultivate?

>And these endlessly patient machines are very good at feeding that curiosity

They're also very good at feeding you factually incorrect information. In comparison, a textbook was crafted by experts in their field, and is often fact checked by many more experts before it becomes published.

[rightbyte]

> My 12-yr-old is not there yet and may never get there.

Wouldn't class room exams enforce that though? Like, imagining LLMs like an older sibling or parent that would help pupils cheat on essays.