People who have a passport card (or book) but don't have another RealID (either because they never bothered, or because their state wanted to charge extra for it). Or, as happened to me once, whose driver's license is expired (only by a couple of days, but that's enough).
2014: Who would not carry their wallet and solely rely on their iPhone to pay for things when running errands?
I understand it's cool to be cynical on HN but: this is a step in the direction for a future world where a lot of countries will let you in with a digital passport.
Now whether you think that's a good thing or not, that's a different story.
I use a passport card, doesn’t contain my home address and works for age/identity verification and TSA (domestic air travel). With that said, TSA IDEMIA hardware that has to make a passport query to identity proof at a checkpoint is a few seconds slower than a driver's license or Global Entry card if that matters to you.
I've never used anything else other than my passport to travel domestically. Main reason being that when I first moved to the US, I was couch surfing and didn't have a permanent address. When I finally got my own apartment and went to get a state ID card, the experience at the DMV made me not want to return to get a real ID card, so I just use my passport and don't have to worry about whether it's in compliance or not.
I use a Global Entry card or US Passport Card. I do not have a "REAL ID". Both my GE card and Passport Card don't have my address, which protects my identity from prying TSA eyes.
I carry my passport for every trip, then leave it in my hotel. Thinking is that if I get robbed/lose my drivers license, I can still board the plane for the return trip home.
Let’s not normalise using your phone, containing all your secrets, as ID. And especially not interacting with it in front of unrestrained representatives of state authority.
Just carry a bit of inert - as inert as possible - plastic instead
You don't have to share your phone, or its secrets, to use this. At the TSA checkpoint, there's a screen that says specifically what information they're asking for, you tap, and your phone shares that. You never lose physical control of your phone. No one even looks at the screen. It's basically tap-to-pay for authentication.
Personally, I fully expect this to gradually become the primary method by which all ID is issued and used. Cell phones are already effectively mandatory to function in our society, so whether you need to target a protest of potential dissidents or an audience of potential customers, it's the perfect one stop shop for our newly emerging highly integrated state+industry power structure.
Does the TSA have any authority to even access your phone? Sure with suspicion they could refer you to the police or something where normal legal standards apply. But they aren't DHS/Customs staff who in the past could demand devices for unloading.
These days, you'll have to keep the plastic in some kind of metallic sleeve. The RFID chip in US Green Cards, and I imagine passport cards as well, is designed to be readable from across a room.
This is exciting, and probably a subtle admission from Apple that states aren't playing ball with their Drivers ID in Wallet approach. Even Apple's home state California initially limited digital IDs to their bottom of the barrel, garbage grade ID app (seriously go look at "mDL California"/"CA DMV Wallet" app, even the splash image is pixelated garbage) before finally allowing IDs to be added to Wallet the Apple way.
This lazy critique has been around for years, but it’s never been true. Just like the drivers license, you don’t need to unlock the phone.
> When you present your license or ID in person, after you authenticate using Face ID or Touch ID, your ID information is presented digitally through encrypted communication between your iPhone or Apple Watch and the identity reader, so you don’t need to unlock, show, or hand over your device. If your device is locked when you present your ID, it stays locked after you present your ID.
This is also a fundamentally naive criticism because we’re at a point where anyone worried about their unlocked device knows that the alternative ranges from being detained for a few hours and missing their flight, to spending a week or two sleeping on a concrete floor in an overcrowded detention center, to being shipped off to a lawless concentration camp in El Salvador. Keeping your phone locked or powered off is no substitute for returning to a constitutional democracy.
The thing I don’t understand about using my phone for identity verification at TSA is that I also need my boarding pass at TSA, which is also on my phone. I can either hand them my drivers license and scan my boarding pass in parallel (fast), hand them a paper boarding pass and maybe use the digital drivers license assuming that airport can support that (waste of paper though), or I can do both on my phone and make the entire interaction take twice as long? What’s the point, genuinely?
At all of the airports I've been to in the last year or two I haven't needed a boarding pass to get through security. Just ID.
That being said every airport I've flown through for the last 2-ish years has had digital IDs or ID scanners so at smaller, or laggard, airports they may still be doing that.
This was a similar issue with android/apple pay at the beginning (at least in the states where card tapping was less common). I expect given enough time it will become more common to verify your age at bars/stores, get through airports, etc with just a phone/watch tap.
SirMaster|8 months ago
devilbunny|8 months ago
okdood64|8 months ago
I understand it's cool to be cynical on HN but: this is a step in the direction for a future world where a lot of countries will let you in with a digital passport.
Now whether you think that's a good thing or not, that's a different story.
toomuchtodo|8 months ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_passport_card
https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/passports/need-pa...
ne0flex|8 months ago
danielfoster|8 months ago
op00to|8 months ago
0cf8612b2e1e|8 months ago
nine_zeros|8 months ago
You need it in countries with haphazard kidnappings - like the US.
IncreasePosts|8 months ago
bananapub|8 months ago
Just carry a bit of inert - as inert as possible - plastic instead
Zanni|8 months ago
zitsarethecure|8 months ago
kylehotchkiss|8 months ago
csande17|8 months ago
kylehotchkiss|8 months ago
unknown|8 months ago
[deleted]
pxoe|8 months ago
tonyhart7|8 months ago
elaborate on that more
bvan|8 months ago
acdha|8 months ago
> When you present your license or ID in person, after you authenticate using Face ID or Touch ID, your ID information is presented digitally through encrypted communication between your iPhone or Apple Watch and the identity reader, so you don’t need to unlock, show, or hand over your device. If your device is locked when you present your ID, it stays locked after you present your ID.
https://support.apple.com/en-us/118260
This is also a fundamentally naive criticism because we’re at a point where anyone worried about their unlocked device knows that the alternative ranges from being detained for a few hours and missing their flight, to spending a week or two sleeping on a concrete floor in an overcrowded detention center, to being shipped off to a lawless concentration camp in El Salvador. Keeping your phone locked or powered off is no substitute for returning to a constitutional democracy.
manchmalscott|8 months ago
vinay427|8 months ago
https://www.afar.com/magazine/no-need-to-show-tsa-your-board...
os2warpman|8 months ago
That being said every airport I've flown through for the last 2-ish years has had digital IDs or ID scanners so at smaller, or laggard, airports they may still be doing that.
arccy|8 months ago
tuckerman|8 months ago
wil421|8 months ago