top | item 44493867

(no title)

schuyler2d | 7 months ago

I don't want to completely refute this because I'm also an amateur and there are a lot of instabilities of consensus, but Baal was at least also the son of El in Canaanite religion which predated an Israeli kingdom.

My understanding is more that Yahvists had more nomadic origins and populated (/conquered, possibly the Levites[1]) a Canaanite cultural context and then there was religious syncreticism and interest in merging them. Depending on the specific passage's history there's either a ret-coning of "all one god" or at least the interpretation that way (including how your links translate those passages).

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Exodus-Richard-Elliott-Friedman/dp/00...

discuss

order

thaumasiotes|7 months ago

> Baal was at least also the son of El in Canaanite religion which predated an Israeli kingdom

Where are you getting this from?

smithkl42|7 months ago

The Wikipedia article is a good place to start:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baal

Like all matters concerning the gods in the ancient near east, it's complex, and every answer has to be qualified. So apparently in some traditions, Baal was the son of Dagan (another fertility god), and in some the son of El (the head of the Canaanite pantheon, often identified with Yahweh even by orthodox Yahwists).

ThalesX|7 months ago

Have you tried googling "baal son of el"? I have no idea on who Baal is, or El, but the discussion sparked my curiosity and that's all I needed to do in order to answer for myself the question "where are you getting this from?".