[mdedetrich]

iirc, btrfs has fixed the issues with raid 5/6 but it requires a breaking change to the on disk format which means you have to create an entirely new partition and copy the data over (you cannot update an existing partition to it). This new on disk format also needs its own testing.

Your point raid 5/6 not being tested heavily by actual users is entirely on point, those enterprise heavy users are only running RAID 10 like configurations.

If you want RAID 5/6, just use ZFS as they have solved all of these issues. I don't know if its due to sheer luck or maybe the fact is that Sun at its time was actually running RAID 5/6 in production (hard drives were not as cheap back then as they are now)?