[ICBTheory]

3. On “He redefines AGI to make his result inevitable”

Sure. I redefined AGI. By using… …the definition from OpenAI, DeepMind, Anthropic, IBM, Goertzel, and Hutter.

So unless those are now fringe newsletters, the definition stands:

- A general-purpose system that autonomously solves a wide range of human-level problems, with competence equivalent to or greater than human performance -

If that’s the target, the contradiction is structural: No symbolic system can operate stably in the kinds of semantic drift, ambiguity, or frame collapse that general intelligence actually requires. So if you think I smuggled in a trap, check your own luggage because the industry packed it for me.