top | item 44714065

(no title)

stelonix | 7 months ago

It is not specific to right wing grifters. Left wing grifters use the same talking points but with a different reason behind. Yet they want to censor the same products: one group based on puritanism & moralism while the other based on feminism & LGBT rights. Both extremes want the same thing.

discuss

order

myko|7 months ago

Reading this it seems to equate feminism and LGBTQ rights with extremism, which doesn't feel correct at all

Terr_|7 months ago

Are there any examples where someone got "de-banked" or "de-payment-processored" because of misogynistic (but legal) content?

Two different people might both want $100 from you, but that isn't enough for an equivalence: I'm sure you'll agree there's an enormous practical difference between the one that does/doesn't think "knife stabs" are a valid tactic. Or even just between two where only one owns a knife.

zahlman|7 months ago

> Are there any examples where someone got "de-banked" or "de-payment-processored" because of misogynistic (but legal) content?

You don't even have to express misogynistic ideas to attract that kind of attention; you only need to question the current mode of politically correct thought.

They tried to prevent the distribution of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatred_(video_game) , and were temporarily successful.

For that matter:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_controversial_video_ga...

> [Super Seducer] came under fire by a number of video game critics; one described it as the "world's sleaziest game",[37] and another criticized the game for "normalizing rape culture"[38] Prior to its release, the game had its crowdfunding campaign suspended by Kickstarter. According to its press release, this was due to "inappropriate content, including but not limited to offensive or pornographic material", and "spamming or abusive behavior, offering rewards in violation of Kickstarter's rules."[39][40]

This is absurd characterization of the gameplay, but the entire concept of "pick-up artistry" causes strong prejudice.

Literal debanking etc., I wouldn't know. I haven't kept tabs on these kinds of stories for many years.

That said, Collective Shout is explicitly arguing that the porn content they're trying to censor via these tactics is inherently misogynistic.

And it wasn't, as far as I can tell, right-wing groups complaining about the Senran Kagura series several years back, either the games or the anime. Just look at the domain names that come up in searches if you try to look that one up; you don't get conservative forums, but you do get ResetEra and VICE, along with the usual "gaming news" rags.

jennyholzer|7 months ago

I don't think it makes sense to label either group of grifters based on stated political affiliation; These groups are linked because they are both grifters.

The politics are just a costume that ingratiates the grifter with their target market.

AlexandrB|7 months ago

I don't get why they're being called grifters. These groups - both left and right - probably genuinely believe this stuff is harmful and are following their beliefs to their logical conclusion. I don't think companies should bow to such pressure, but that doesn't make them "grifters".

"Grifter" seems like the new shorthand for "person I don't like".

holsta|7 months ago

> Both extremes want the same thing.

Citation needed. The 'extreme' feminism & LGBT tends to revolve around identical pay, being able to walk down the street without getting assaulted or being able to work without being harassed or discriminated against.

pseudo0|7 months ago

Feminist groups also regularly try to get games banned from Steam, typically for sexism or violence against women. Eg.

> Women in Games CEO Dr Marie-Claire Isaaman has called on Valve to “act urgently” and remove the game from Steam, saying the game’s content “is not only vile and dangerous, but also actively promotes the dehumanisation of women and girls.”

https://www.videogameschronicle.com/news/women-in-games-call...

zahlman|7 months ago

>The 'extreme' feminism & LGBT tends to revolve around

There are countless statements from feminist authority figures that are impossible to reconcile with this claim. But HN is not the place to have this argument, or even to attempt to turn it into a discussion; and elsewhere on the Internet, I have repeatedly seen people persecuted as misogynists simply for collating such evidence.