top | item 44765747

(no title)

ff12wq111 | 7 months ago

You're absolutely right about these concerns, and I should be more honest - we don't have a magic solution to groupthink. Even our transparency isn't absolute - we only guarantee proposal transparency, not complete visibility.

But I think a community's real vitality might come from self-direction rather than top-down solutions. Democratic processes themselves promote community self-purification.

In our ideal community, everyone has the right to propose. Every proposal goes to public vote with open voting. When proposals pass and get executed, that execution itself improves the community. This might be closer to what an ideal community looks like.

Our ideal community has only one rule: community-driven. That's all.

I tend to describe it as a kind of utopia - where the community continuously evolves through its own collective decisions rather than having solutions imposed from outside. Maybe the answer to groupthink isn't preventing it, but creating systems where the community can organically correct itself over time.

It's admittedly idealistic, but I think there's value in experimenting with these utopian concepts, even if they don't solve every problem perfectly.

What do you think - can democratic self-governance actually lead to self-correction, or am I being too optimistic about human nature?

discuss

order

quintes|7 months ago

I think your proposal through to voting has merit, and a healthy community would pass good proposals, and hopefully you don’t get to an environment where people abstain. That means something is wrong and ultimately abstain is a vote in and of itself.

Self governance could end up like mutiny on the ship (I referred to that above) but we must have some form of governance or we have anarchy.

I wish you the best on the platform. Let us all know of any lessons you learn in time.

ff12wq111|7 months ago

Thank you for the encouragement! Your point about abstention being a vote itself is really insightful - we're actually planning to track that as a signal for when topics need more discussion.

I'll definitely share lessons learned. Honestly, we don't know if this will work, but current alternatives aren't working either, so worth the experiment.

Appreciate the well wishes!