[curiousguy7374]

But I still don’t know what it’s like to be a bat

Also, if there is a soul, then how can we be confident concisouness arises from physical means? If there is a soul, it is the perfect means to differentiate concisouness and p-zombies.

[mensetmanusman]

There is a soul if you believe we aren’t all p-zombies. (Soul is the all encompassing word to distinguish this. Maybe there are better words?)

[curiousguy7374]

Yeah what I was trying to get at was the post I replied to said concisouness is a physical process, and the more interesting question is if souls exist.

My thinking is if soul’s exist, then we can’t call concisouness a purely physical process yet