top | item 45212966

(no title)

AftHurrahWinch | 5 months ago

This: https://vincentarelbundock.github.io/Rdatasets/doc/dslabs/po...

discuss

order

jstanley|5 months ago

That's circular reasoning.

My model says there's a 70% chance of Foo, and that is actually accurate. How do you know it's accurate? Because my model said so.

It might have been accurate! 30% probability events happen 3 times out of 10. We just have no way to know if it truly was accurate.

softwaredoug|5 months ago

You can “know” because we have decades of polling and election outcomes.

It’s not black and white “know”, 70% is the mean of a probability distribution.

It’s more accurate to say, this model predicts “Foo” because historically polls like this favor Foo 70% of the time. But these are probabilities and have wide errors. It’s on the reader to have a level of statistical knowledge.

These are more handicaps than “predictions”. The same way we predict whether it might rain tomorrow, who might wins tomorrows game, without a Time Machine.