top | item 45374150

(no title)

matteotom | 5 months ago

What metric are you looking at when you say "the size of government has vastly and consistently outgrown the private sector" - AFAICT, excluding 2020 and 2021 (which I think is reasonable), the federal budget has been between 17% and 25% of GDP for the past 50 years (where the fluctuations are more a function of variable GDP).

The number of federal government employees has also remained mostly flat for the past 50 years (and IIRC most growth in overall public sector employment comes from schools).

discuss

order

mondrian|5 months ago

Comparing it to GDP doesn’t seem to make sense. Maybe to government revenue.

AnimalMuppet|5 months ago

No, the claim was that it has outgrown the private sector. GDP is in fact a good proxy for that claim.

Outgrowing government revenue is a different claim.

neffy|5 months ago

No, it does make sense. Most of the purported growth in government spending is just using raw figures, and not correcting for either inflation or monetary expansion. It is a convenient mistake.