top | item 45404915

(no title)

gurumeditations | 5 months ago

Government is just organized volunteering. You’re describing a government. You created your own mini government for your road maintenance.

discuss

order

mothballed|5 months ago

If I (willingly) don't pay my taxes someone will put me in a tiny cage, violently ("tax evasion").

If I don't fix my road, I just can't go anywhere, which obviously forces me to voluntarily fix it. If I don't voluntarily fix it, I'm stuck until someone comes along with a backhoe, and given only the tiniest % of people will purposefully sabotage their ability to go buy groceries, the burden of having to fix a neighbors road is so miniscule that it fits well within tolerable natural rates of charity.

The end result is the county roads are enforced by violence (tax man will toss grandma out of her house if she doesn't pay up, and assault her if she resists), while the private roads are enforced by a mixture of voluntary action on your own property and some relatively rare charity for those who just don't give a shit if they ever leave their house.

The difference here is the government can initiate violence against me, while the people involved in the private roads cannot.

avmich|5 months ago

So how the tragedy of commons problem is solved?