top | item 45417059

(no title)

jjani | 5 months ago

Gemini 2.5 Pro = Long context king, image input king

GPT-5 = Overengineering/complexity/"enterprise" king

Claude = "Get straightforwaed shit done efficiently" king

discuss

order

CuriouslyC|5 months ago

On the plus side, GPT5 is very malleable, so you CAN prompt it away from that, whereas it's very hard to prompt Claude into producing hard code: even with a nearly file by file breakdown of a task, it'll occasionally run into an obstacle and just give up and make a mock or top implementation, basically diverge from the entire plan, then do its own version.

jjani|5 months ago

Absolutely, sometimes you want, or indeed need such complexity. Some work in settings where they would want it all of the time. IMHO, most people, most of the time don't really want it, and don't want to have to prompt it every time to avoid it. That's why I think it's still very useful to build up experience with the three frontier models, so you can choose according to the situation.