top | item 45441593

(no title)

mike_ivanov | 5 months ago

All GUI apps are different, each being unhappy in its own way. Moated fiefdoms they are, scattered within the boundaries of their operating system. CLI is a common ground, an integration plaza where the peers meet, streams flow and signals are exchanged. No commitment needs to be made to enter this information bazaar. The closest analog in the GUI world is Smalltalk, but again - you need to pledge your allegiance before entering one.

discuss

order

array_key_first|5 months ago

We have systems for highly interoperable and compostable GUI applications - think NextSTEP or, modern day, dbus, to a lesser extent.

Really, GUIs can be formed of a public API with graphics slapped on top. They usually aren't, but they can be.

wpm|5 months ago

I weep for what happened to AppKit/Cocoa

topaz0|5 months ago

Just because it says compostable on the container doesn't mean it will actually break down in a reasonable amount of time on your home compost heap, or that they don't leach some environmentally harmful chemicals in the process.

antonvs|5 months ago

Many modern web apps are just APIs with a browser GUI.

mike_ivanov|5 months ago

I'd say ROS (Robot Operating System) is the closest to this ideal.

p_ing|5 months ago

> Moated fiefdoms they are, scattered within the boundaries of their operating system.

Yet highly preferred over CLI applications to the common end user.

CLI-only would have stunted the growth of computing.

anthk|5 months ago

I'd love something like the Emacs approach. Multi-UI's. Graphical, but with an M-x (or anything else) command line prompt in order to do UI tasks scriptable, from within the application or from the outside.

jadeopteryx|5 months ago

Apple ShortCuts and AppleScript integration is also cool.