top | item 45544414

Why LLMs cannot reach GenAI, but why it looked like they could

1 points| MakeAJiraTicket | 4 months ago |haversine.substack.com

2 comments

order

CarbonBasedUnit|4 months ago

From the article: "If I ask you to think through a problem you don’t think in symbols, numbers, or any other representation. You think in words, and therefore your ability to think relies on your ability to deploy words. "

Author hasn't done his homework. The belief thoughts = words has been well-debunked. The first hit from a lazy Google search is a Scientific American article all about it, helpfully titled 'You Don't Need Words to Think".

https://archive.ph/KjJ1R

Or, if you like scientific papers better, see "Language and thought are not the same thing: evidence from neuroimaging and neurological patients"

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4874898/

MakeAJiraTicket|4 months ago

The author explicitly states that there are other types of thought, this is about structured reasoning.