top | item 45622548

(no title)

kobalsky | 4 months ago

MCP servers are basically a tool call registries, how could it be worse than a regular tool call?

discuss

order

behnamoh|4 months ago

an MCP server can run code outside of the domain of tools that it supports, tool call can't

TeMPOraL|4 months ago

Tools are literally function calls with extra steps. MCPs are interpreters of those function calls.

Same stuff, different name - only thing that's changed is that Anthropic got people to agree on RPC protocol.

It's not like it's a new idea, either. MCP isn't much different from SOAP or DCOM - but it works where the older approaches didn't, because LLMs are able to understand API definitions and natural-language documentation, and then map between those APIs (and user input) on the fly.